Japanese high court rules denying same-sex marriage unconstitutional - MASHAHER

Key Points

Japan is the only G7 nation that excludes same-sex couples from the right to legally marry.
Thursday saw a Japanese high court rule that denying same-sex marriage is unconstitutional.
The ruling doesn’t change or overturn the current law describing marriage as between a man and a woman.

A Japanese high court has ruled that denying same-sex marriage is unconstitutional and called for urgent government action to address the lack of any law allowing for such unions.

The court does not have the power to overturn the current marriage law, which has been interpreted to restrict marriage as between a man and a woman.

Government offices may continue to deny marriage status to same-sex couples unless the existing law is revised to include LGBTQI couples, or a new law is enacted that allows for other types of unions.

The Sapporo High Court ruling on Thursday said not allowing same-sex couples to marry and enjoy the same benefits as straight couples violates their fundamental right to have a family.

A lower court issued a similar ruling earlier on Thursday, becoming the sixth district court to do so.

Plaintiffs hold a banner before the ruling on same-sex marriage at the Tokyo District Court in Tokyo, Japan, 14 March 2024. Source: AAP / Jiji Press

But the Tokyo District Court ruling was only a partial victory for Japan’s LGBTQI community calling for equal marriage rights, as it doesn’t change or overturn the current civil union law that describes marriage as between a man and a woman.

Five previous court decisions in various cities said Japan’s policy of denying same-sex marriage is either unconstitutional or nearly so.

However, unlike the Sapporo ruling on Friday, none of the low-level courts clearly deemed the Japanese government’s existing policy to reject same-sex couples unconstitutional.

Japan is the only member of the Group of Seven nations that still excludes same-sex couples from the right to legally marry and receive spousal benefits.

Support for marriage equality has grown among the Japanese public in recent years, but the governing Liberal Democratic Party, known for its conservative family values and reluctance to promote gender equality and sexual diversity, remains opposed to the campaign.

In the Tokyo ruling, the court said the right to marry, have a family and enjoy advantages marriage brings – such as tax deductions and social security benefits – are guaranteed for everyone, and that lack of the legal right to same-sex couples deprives them of their basic right.

Plaintiffs and others shows a banner in front of Sapporo Hight Court in Sapporo, Hokkaido, northern Japan Thursday, 14 March, 2024. Source: AAP / AP

The Tokyo ruling also acknowledged the right for anyone to live based on their sexuality and sexual identity, and the traditional family values and marriage are changing, and equality of same-sex marriage is increasingly accepted in international and corporate communities.

The court said the government’s lack of effort to implement legal marriage equality is not unconstitutional, but expressed hope for the parliament to enact a law for same-sex marriage.

Marriage equality is now recognised in dozens of countries, not only in Western countries like Greece and the United States but also in Asia.

Nepal began allowing same-sex marriage registration starting in 2023, according to the Marriage for All Japan, a civil group supporting the lawsuits.

While Japan’s conservative government has been criticised as stonewalling diversity, recent surveys show a majority of Japanese back legalising same-sex marriage.

Support among the business community has rapidly increased.

Tokyo enacted an LGBTQI awareness promotion law in June that critics said was watered down.

The Supreme Court separately ruled that Japan’s law requiring compulsory sterilisation surgery for transgender people to officially change their gender is unconstitutional.

Source Agencies